By Sara Khan · WeProms Digital · November 21, 2026
The belief goes like this: nobody opens Google any more, everyone just asks ChatGPT, and the SAR 2,650 a month that a Pakistani-run perfume house in Jeddah’s Al-Balad souk pays for search engine optimisation (SEO) — the work of making a shop’s pages readable, accurate and trustworthy enough for search engines to recommend — is money straight down the drain.
That sentence travelled fast across the Gulf in November 2026, and it sounded most convincing over karak coffee in Jeddah, where the fragrance trade runs deep in the Pakistani merchant community of the historic quarter. On 18 November, Marc Benioff, chief executive of Salesforce, posted two words on X — “Goodbye SEO” — telling followers that customers “aren’t searching anymore” and instead ask Claude, ChatGPT and Gemini which brands to buy, leaving “No click. No referral. Nothing in your analytics.” What the chief executive did not mention is that Salesforce’s own guide for new businesses, published on 11 September by the company’s SEO senior director, Graham Hardt, and linked from the FAQ of the very tool he was promoting, states plainly that “SEO is still the foundation,” as Search Engine Journal reported and as Salesforce’s own guide still reads today.
A company that sells AI-visibility dashboards is telling its own customers to keep the SEO foundation. That is a sales pitch folding in on itself, not a research finding.
The goodbye post and the guide it links to disagree
Benioff was promoting Palmata, a tool that monitors what AI assistants say about a business, recommends changes, and simulates their effect; it arrived inside Salesforce through the acquisition of Contentful completed on 1 September. Monitoring is a legitimate need — a Jeddah shop owner absolutely should know what ChatGPT says when someone asks where to buy dehn al oud. The leap from “you should monitor AI answers” to “SEO is finished” is where the argument breaks, and the professionals who build AI search visibility for a living were quick to say so.
“AI search optimization goes beyond traditional SEO, but it certainly doesn’t replace it.” — Aleyda Solis, SEO consultant and founder of Orainti, quoted by Search Engine Journal
Solis added a distinction worth writing on the shop wall: watching what an AI platform says about your brand and actually improving your visibility, recommendations and business outcomes are two different jobs. A dashboard reports the weather; it does not build the roof. Salesforce’s guide, for its part, describes SEO and answer engine optimisation (AEO) — the practice of shaping your business information so AI answer engines quote it accurately — as “two visibility layers for the same audience,” and advises businesses to track “both sets of metrics.” So the firm’s chief executive said goodbye to a layer its own documentation calls foundational.
The pattern repeats every time an answer layer appears: a headline declares the old work dead, a tool is sold, and eighteen months later the shops that kept their foundations are the ones the new layer cites. Jeddah’s perfume traders have watched this film before, from Yellow Pages to Instagram feeds; the souk always outlives the medium.
The buyer moved desks, not buildings
Nothing about the Jeddah customer has actually changed except the first question she asks. She still researches a SAR 450 bottle before buying it; she simply begins by asking ChatGPT in Arabic for the best oud shops near Al-Balad, then cross-checks Google Maps ratings, then — because this is how our community has always shopped — asks the family WhatsApp group whether the price is fair. Research from Redseer’s 2026 Voice of Customer study found that roughly 37% of Saudi consumers use AI platforms for shopping research and comparison. Read that number carefully: nearly two in three Saudi shoppers still begin somewhere other than an AI chat, and even the 37% finish on pages, maps listings and reviews that AI answers point them towards.
Google, whose engine supplies much of the answer layer, has stated its position in its own AI optimisation guide: “From Google Search’s perspective, optimizing for generative AI search is optimizing for the search experience, and thus still SEO.” The supplier of the answers is telling Jeddah shop owners that the work has not changed category. An AI answer with no source is a guess, and engines prefer to recommend shops they can verify — which means the readable, consistent page remains the entry ticket to every recommendation.
Ignite Visibility’s AEO guide splits AI visibility into three outcomes: a brand mention, a linked citation — the AI answer quoting your page as its source, usually with a link — and a full recommendation. None of the three guarantees a website visit, and all three draw on the same raw material: pages, listings and reviews that a machine can read and check. Cancellation shrinks exactly that material.
The stakes are rising while the debate runs. Saudi Arabia’s fragrance market was worth US$2.9 billion in 2025 and is projected to reach US$5.5 billion by 2030, according to the Beautyworld Middle East report cited by WWD. A market nearly doubling in five years brings first-time buyers with no family recommendation to lean on — new customers who will ask somebody, and the answer will name the shops whose information is complete. National market growth, on its own, proves nothing about one shop on one street in Al-Balad; it simply raises the cost of being the shop the answer skips.
The imam test: recommendation is recognition
Watch what happens any Friday after jumu’ah prayers at a Jeddah mosque. Somebody asks where to buy good oud for Eid gifts, and the imam — or the uncle standing beside him — names the shop he personally knows, on the street where it actually sits. Nobody ranks anybody; recognition does the whole job. An AI assistant behaves like that imam at inhuman scale: it recommends only what it can confidently describe, and confidence comes from information that matches everywhere.
What actually drives a recommendation is consistency. Your Google Business Profile carrying the same hours, address and Arabic trading name as your website; product pages naming mukhallat, dehn al oud and bakhoor in both Arabic and English; reviews that mention the products you actually sell. We see the same mechanics when Riyadh customers ask an AI for a tailor — the shops that get named are the ones whose details agree across Google Maps, their own site and their social profiles. The same discipline decides which Eid gift boxes appear in AI shopping answers, and it is why Gulf perfume sellers who worked out how to get an attar shop recommended on ChatGPT started with listings and bilingual pages, not with a new dashboard subscription.
None of that work is glamorous, and all of it is SEO by Google’s own definition. The engines changed the front door; they did not change what makes a shop worth walking into.
Where the cancel-the-contract crowd have a point
Here the essay owes the cancellation crowd its due, because one of their complaints is correct. Pedro Dias, a technical SEO product manager who once worked at Google, put it in a sentence every retainer holder should pin above the till:
“SEO isn’t traffic. It never has been.” — Pedro Dias, quoted by Search Engine Journal
If your monthly SAR 2,650 retainer delivers a PDF of ranking screenshots and never mentions WhatsApp enquiries, shop visits or actual bottles sold, cancel it with a clear conscience — and then replace it with visibility work tied to revenue, not with nothing. The arithmetic keeps the decision honest. Worked example, illustrative — substitute your own costs: a 12-millilitre bottle of dehn al oud retails at SAR 450 and carries SAR 185 in oil, bottle, packaging and card, leaving SAR 265 of contribution — what remains of the sale price after product and packaging costs. A SAR 2,650 monthly retainer, assumed to be fees only, breaks even at ten bottles a month, which is barely one basket every three days even outside Ramadan. The stop-or-scale rule follows from the same sum: if by the second Ramadan the contract cannot point to enquiries traceable to at least ten bottles a month, renegotiate the deliverables or move the budget.
The part of SEO that genuinely died deserved to die. Lily Ray, writing on Search Engine Journal, traces the same thread from Google’s 2003 instruction to “make pages for users, not for search engines” to the March 2024 scaled-content abuse policy that now catches AI-generated listicle flooding. Content made for engines at scale, with no human standing behind it, has ended the same way in every decade; today’s version simply produces faster. A Jeddah perfume house that was paying for keyword-stuffed pages was wasting money in 2019 and is wasting it now — but that is an argument for better SEO, not for none.
What a Jeddah perfume house should keep paying for
Keep paying for the foundation, and demand it prove itself monthly. A complete Google Business Profile with correct Ramadan hours; bilingual product pages that name the actual blends, whether the storefront runs on Salla, Zid or plain WordPress; a steady reviews routine that invites every happy customer, with their permission, and never buys a single fake star; and, above all, the perfumer’s own story. Lily Ray’s argument deserves the last word here: as machine-generated content becomes nearly free, real, identifiable people — the family behind the counter since the grandfather’s first stall — become the clearest trust signal available to both customers and the engines that advise them. Overseas Pakistani family businesses hold that asset by default; most never put it on the page.
Timing turns the foundation into seasonal revenue. Ramadan 1448 is expected to begin on 8 February 2027, subject to the official moon sighting, per the Umm al-Qura calendar. Build backwards from that date: interest in Eid gifting builds from the second half of January 2027, deposits for gift boxes open six weeks before the expected Eid al-Fitr date in early March 2027, and the pages an AI engine can cite — Ramadan hours, gift sets, delivery terms — must exist eight to ten weeks before 8 February, because an engine cannot recommend a page that has not been written. The comparison is worth making with the trader your family still visits in Lahore, who never bought an advertisement in thirty years; he stayed findable, consistent and known, and the customers kept arriving. That is the surviving skill. The souk moved into the answer; it did not disappear.
The principle that survives every headline
Search did not die; it dissolved into answers, and the answers cite pages built by the work too many shops are now cancelling. A Jeddah perfume house that drops SEO in 2026 to “go all in on AI” will, within two Ramadans, struggle to appear in the very answers it switched for — the prediction is falsifiable, and the mechanism is simple: recommendations cite maintained pages, and cancelled contracts maintain nothing. The decision criterion is one sentence. Cancel the contract that reports traffic; keep paying for the work that makes you the answer.
Read next: When Should My Riyadh Karahi House Post for Ramadan 2027? and ChatGPT Stopped Recommending My Halal Sweet Shop. Should I Worry?
Based on our experience working with perfume retailers, halal grocers and family restaurants across Saudi Arabia, the UAE and the UK, WeProms Digital builds exactly the visibility layer this essay describes: consistent business information, bilingual pages AI engines can quote, review growth with real customers, and reporting that ties visibility to enquiries instead of screenshots. WeProms is an SEO agency trusted by halal businesses in the UK and the Gulf, and its SEO services for Gulf and diaspora shops begin with a plain audit of what an AI engine sees when it looks for your shop today. Talk to the team on WhatsApp +92 300 0133399 or through the contact page — replies land within UK and Gulf business hours.
Sources & References
- Search Engine Journal — Salesforce CEO Says ‘Goodbye SEO.’ Salesforce’s SEO Guide Disagrees — November 20, 2026
- Salesforce — SEO vs. AEO: Strategies, Tips, Benefits, and Tools for New Businesses — September 2026
- Google Search Central — AI Optimization Guide — accessed November 2026
- Redseer — Who Owns the Customer When AI Owns the Answer? — 2026
- WWD — Beautyworld at 30: The Gulf Beauty Market in Numbers — 2026
- Search Engine Journal — Why Building Trust Through Real People Stands the Test of Time in SEO & AI Search — November 20, 2026
- Ignite Visibility — Show Up in AI Answers: A Marketer’s Guide to Answer Engine Optimization — November 19, 2026
- TaqwimSA — Ramadan 1448 AH Calendar (Umm al-Qura) — accessed November 2026
Additional reading from industry feeds:



