By Hamza Ali · WeProms Digital · November 20, 2026
Take one hypothetical store, numbers illustrative — substitute your own: a Pakistani-owned abaya and modest fashion shop in Luton, 380 orders a month through Shopify, dispatched with Royal Mail Tracked 48, average order £58. Last quarter the owner refunded £640 across eleven “it never arrived” claims. Courier scans show nine of those eleven parcels delivered, four with doorstep photos. That is not shrinkage. That is refund abuse, and it has quietly become the most common fraud type in online retail — ahead of stolen cards.
Refund abuse — a buyer receives the order, then falsely claims it never arrived or arrived damaged, to get the money back and keep the goods. Nobody budgets for it. Stores serving Muslim customers feel it twice, because Eid and shaadi gifting sends parcels to third addresses all season, which is the exact claim shape that is hardest to argue against: the person paying and the person receiving are different people.
Most owners treat these claims like weather.
Weather you cannot argue with. A leak with a named cause, you can fix — and the claims log usually names it. We see the same pattern in nearly every store account we open: refunds cluster around gift-shipping weeks, not randomly.
The industry data agrees. Practical Ecommerce’s fraud outlook for 2027 reported the trend plainly:
“A Q4 2025 survey from the Merchant Risk Council found that, on average, the percentage of fraudulent ecommerce orders increased from 3.0% to 3.5%.”
At 3.5%, roughly one order in 29 is fraudulent before you have sold anything extra — on 380 monthly orders, about 13 bad orders. The survey polled merchants globally, so it does not pin your Luton store’s exact rate; treat it as direction, then read your own last 90 days of claims. That log is the only source of truth that pays you back.
The Eid vector nobody writes into the policy
Eid gifting creates a fraud vector no generic policy covers. A customer in Luton orders a gift abaya for her cousin in Bradford; the parcel lands with the cousin; the cousin forgets to mention it; the buyer claims non-delivery and opens a payment dispute. Sometimes it is genuine confusion inside one family. Sometimes the cousin is invented. Either way, the store pays.
UK law frames who wins. Under Section 29 of the Consumer Rights Act 2015, goods stay at the retailer’s risk until they reach the customer or a person the customer identified to receive them — a point Parliament’s own consumer law briefing repeats, and one reason a “delivered” GPS pin alone does not close the question. A delivery scan naming the recipient your customer chose is strong. A photo of an unnamed porch is weak. Build your checkout and carrier settings around that difference.
Anyone who has queued at the halal butcher on the last Friday of Ramadan knows what a demand spike does to standards. Fraudsters run the same calendar. Ramadan 2027 is expected to begin around 8 February 2027, with Eid al-Fitr expected around 9–10 March 2027, subject to moon sighting (Islamic calendar trackers). Count six weeks back from that expected date: your tightened delivery rules should be live by late January 2027, not patched mid-Ramadan.
Add a recipient-name and phone field for gift orders at checkout this week. One field, and half these disputes get shorter.
Where the money actually goes
Run the numbers on one order (illustrative — substitute your own costs):
| Line | Amount |
|---|---|
| Order value (abaya, illustrative) | £58.00 |
| Product cost | £22.00 |
| Packaging | £2.50 |
| Royal Mail Tracked 48 | £3.20 |
| Card processing fee | £1.50 |
| Contribution per clean order | £28.80 |
A false “never arrived” claim refunds the £58, burns the £5.70 of postage and packaging already spent, and still forfeits most of the processing fee — Stripe’s refund documentation is explicit that fees on refunded charges are not returned. Call it £65 gone, with a £22 abaya still walking around out there. Two claims erase the profit of roughly four clean orders.
Now stack that against ad spend. A £300 month on Google Ads at a £20 cost per order buys about 15 orders — £432 of contribution, £132 net after media. Two false claims eat £130 of that. Three sink the month. That is the entire business case for prevention, and it is the arithmetic most owners never run until the disputes land.
The macro pressure is not easing either. UK Finance’s Annual Fraud Report 2026 put remote-purchase card fraud at £423.5 million across 3.2 million cases in 2025. A national figure proves nothing about your claim rate in Luton — what it does prove is that the pool of compromised cards keeps refilling, and small independent stores are the soft end of that market.
Pull your last 90 days of claims and tag each one delivered, genuinely lost, or unclear. Five minutes a month, and you stop guessing.
The five patterns heading into 2027
The Merchant Risk Council survey ranks five fraud types, and the ranking matters more than any single number. Refund and return abuse led, at 41% of merchants reporting it. Real-time payment fraud followed at 38%. Credential theft and account takeover hit 37%. Card testing held at 33%, unchanged from the prior year. Identity theft rounded it out at 31%.
Quick definitions, because the names sound scarier than the fixes. Real-time payments are bank-to-bank transfers that settle in seconds and are close to impossible to reverse, so every open-banking payment should be treated like cash in an envelope. Card testing is criminals placing tiny orders with stolen card numbers to see which cards still work; watch for bursts of small declined transactions and switch on velocity rules in your Shopify checkout. Account takeover is subtler — a fraudster inside a real customer’s account, with the real order history, changing the delivery address right after a password reset. Identity theft is drifting into synthetic identities: names, addresses and photos assembled by AI to look like real shoppers. None of these need new software to fight.
The AI line is the one to sit with. The Practical Ecommerce outlook warns that generated photographs of “damaged” goods and cloned courier emails are now cheap to produce at volume. Your evidence pack no longer competes with a liar’s word; it competes with a liar’s production values. Timestamped courier scans and named-recipient delivery beat a generated photo every time — but only if you collected them before the claim arrived.
One alert worth setting: more than three claims inside seven days from accounts under sixty days old pauses those orders for manual review. It is free to configure in Shopify, and it catches most testing bursts early.
What actually holds up in a dispute
The fix is simple. Make the evidence write itself. Five layers, in order of strength:
- Named-recipient delivery. Royal Mail, DPD and Evri business accounts all export proof-of-delivery with timestamps. File the export monthly, not after the dispute opens.
- Signature on delivery above £50. It costs pence per parcel, and it turns “left in porch” into “signed by S. Khan”.
- 3-D Secure — the extra bank verification step (Visa Secure, Mastercard ID Check) that shifts liability for “unauthorised payment” claims to the issuing bank. Stripe Radar can force it for first-time customers.
- Address verification. A billing and shipping mismatch is not proof of fraud, but it is a reason to hold the order for an hour and check.
- The delivery-confirmation message, sent within the hour. The same UK halal shops that automate their back-in-stock emails should automate this the same way. Ready-to-paste WhatsApp template:
“Assalamu alaikum [Name], order [#123] was delivered today at [time] to [postcode area]. If anything is wrong, reply within 48 hours and we will put it right, insha’Allah. Reply STOP to stop delivery updates.”
That message is transactional — the customer asked for it by ordering. Keep offers and promotions out of it entirely; for those, collect separate consent on your site and show a visible opt-out on every send.
Then use the law honestly. A chargeback — the buyer asks their bank to reverse the payment instead of asking you — is answered through the card scheme’s representment process, with your evidence pack, before the scheme’s deadline. The 14-day cancellation right under the Consumer Contracts Regulations 2013 is a change-of-mind right that starts after receipt; it is a different animal from a non-delivery claim, and your policy page should say so in plain English. For serial claimants, file with Action Fraud, keep the police reference number, and quote it in your reply. The tone of the conversation changes immediately.
Our house rule, from the UK and Gulf store accounts we review: under £20, refund quietly and blacklist the buyer; between £20 and £50, let the customer’s history decide; above £50, dispute every single claim with the full evidence pack. Your honest regulars — the very shoppers paper stamp loyalty cards fail to bring back — should never feel these rules; blacklist quietly, never loudly. Disagree with the thresholds if you like. Just write your rule down before Eid week, not during it.
The pre-Eid checklist we run with stores
- Export the last 90 days of claims; mark each delivered, genuinely lost, or unclear.
- Add a recipient-name and phone field for gift orders at checkout.
- Switch on signature-on-delivery above £50 with your carrier.
- Force 3-D Secure for first-time customers in Stripe Radar.
- Set the three-claims-in-seven-days alert for accounts under sixty days old.
- Split your refund policy wording: change-of-mind returns versus non-delivery claims.
- Automate the delivery-confirmation WhatsApp message or email, with the STOP opt-out.
- File Action Fraud reports for repeat claimants and keep the reference numbers.
- Set a calendar reminder for late January 2027 — rules live six weeks before the expected Eid al-Fitr date of 9–10 March 2027, subject to moon sighting.
If your average order sits under £20, a no-questions refund policy is usually cheaper than the arguing. Above £50, an airtight dispute pack is cheaper than the refunds. The stores that win this season are not the ones with solicitors on speed dial; they are the ones whose evidence assembled itself before the claim existed.
Read next: When Manchester Searches ‘Best Abaya Shops’, Google’s AI Answers First and Should My Birmingham Abaya Boutique Run One Instagram Ad or Three?.
Based on our experience working with halal and diaspora-owned stores across the UK and the Gulf, stores that close the refund-abuse leak recover the cost within a single peak season. WeProms Digital, an ecommerce marketing agency for Shopify and marketplace sellers, builds the checkout rules, tracking exports and delivery-confirmation email flows that make fraud expensive for the fraudster — senior-level work without a London price tag. Email hello@weproms.com, message WhatsApp +92 300 0133399 (replies in UK and Gulf business hours), or start at weproms.com/contact-us.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can I refuse a refund when Royal Mail tracking says delivered?
Not automatically. Under Section 29 of the Consumer Rights Act 2015, goods remain at your risk until they reach the customer or someone the customer identified to receive them, so a porch photo alone may not settle it. A delivery scan naming the recipient your customer chose is far stronger. Decline only with that evidence; otherwise open a carrier investigation and refund once it concludes.
How do I report fake refund claims in the UK?
File with Action Fraud, the UK’s national fraud reporting centre, at actionfraud.police.uk/report, and keep the police reference number. Report the same claim to your carrier — Royal Mail, DPD and Evri all investigate suspected false non-delivery claims. Quote both reference numbers when you reply to the customer.
Do I lose the card processing fee when I refund an order?
Yes, in most cases. Stripe’s refund documentation states that processing fees on refunded charges are not returned, and Shopify Payments follows the same card-scheme mechanics. Budget every false claim at the refund amount plus the lost fee plus the fulfilment you already paid for — roughly £65 on a £58 order in our illustrative numbers.
Should I refund small claims just to be done with them?
Usually, yes, under £20 — the staff time and chargeback risk cost more than the refund. Between £20 and £50, check the customer’s order history first. Above £50, dispute every claim with your full evidence pack: courier export, named recipient, signature, confirmation message. Silent blacklisting protects your margin; public accusations create liability.
Can WeProms set up these protections for my store?
Yes. WeProms Digital sets up checkout rules, 3-D Secure enforcement, delivery-confirmation flows and claims tracking for halal and diaspora-owned stores across the UK, Gulf and North America, based on our experience with exactly this failure pattern. Message hello@weproms.com or WhatsApp +92 300 0133399 and we will review your last 90 days of claims before quoting anything.
About WeProms Digital
WeProms Digital is a Lahore-based ecommerce operations and growth agency working with overseas Pakistani and halal-minded business owners across London, Birmingham, Manchester, Luton, Toronto, Dubai and beyond.
The team specialises in ecommerce marketing, analytics and tracking setup, and lifecycle email flows, with a track record of building checkout and evidence systems that hold up under peak-season disputes.
Get in touch: hello@weproms.com · WhatsApp +92 300 0133399 (replies in UK and Gulf business hours) · weproms.com/contact-us
Sources & References
- Practical Ecommerce — Top Ecommerce Fraud Risks for 2027 — November 19, 2026
- UK Finance — Annual Fraud Report 2026 press release — 2026
- Legislation.gov.uk — Consumer Rights Act 2015, Section 29
- Legislation.gov.uk — Consumer Contracts Regulations 2013, Regulation 30
- Stripe — Refunds documentation
- Action Fraud — Report fraud
- UK House of Commons Library — Consumer rights law briefing CBP-10614
- The Pillars — Ramadan and Eid 2027 expected dates
Additional reading from industry feeds:



